1) The Man Trap
McCoy's ex-girlfriend and her scientist husband are under atack from a salt vampire.
Er....OK, this episode is pretty good in places but the plot is so rubbish I almost fell off the chair laughing! Bones can't see that his ex is not his ex. What a laugh. Spock not behaving right, urgh and Kirk has about the most loud scream I've ever heard on a bloke. Watch on a rainy day if you must.
2) Charlie X
An orphan teenager with telekenetic powers wreaks havoc on the Enterprise
Better than The Man Trap but still not into quality yet. The actor who plays Charlie is either very believable or crap, there's no middle ground. Good tension when the telekenetic race shows up and takes Charlie away though.
3) Where No Man Has Gone Before
The Enterprise flies beyond the edge of the galaxy and Kirk's best mate starts to mutate into a superhuman
This was actually the second pilot shown so it doesn't make sense that it's the third in order. Very good episode this one, action packed and pacey with some good acting (especially from Shatner when he realises he has to kill Mitchell). Spock's solution to Mitchell's problem is pretty cold blooded! Good fight scene but why couldn't they hire some stuntmen who actually LOOKED like Shatner and the other guy? Also this is the first time Kirk gets his shirt ripped in a punch-up. Good ep.
4) The Naked Time
The crew lose their inhibitions after coming into contact with a strange water based disease.
Good acting, duff idea. The scene where Sulu goes on a chopping spree is fun, Shatner reigns in the overacting for his little jaunt, and Nimoy is very believable when he seccumbs. Overall good entertainment but the story (although Sci-Fi) is duff duff duff.
5) The Enemy Within
Kirk is split into 2 after a transporter accident.
The first and most original transporter accident episode is the best episode of the early ones. We learn how far Shatner will go to overact when the evil half goes mad on the bridge. We see the Vulcan nerve pinch for the first time too. Very rewatchable episode, with a few surprises thrown in for good measure. Also this is the first episode where Bones says 'He's dead, Jim.'
6) Mudd's Women
Harry Mudd has given 3 fit babes a drug to make them even more beautiful.
Pretty daft this one, but shows Star Trek is not afraid of comedy. Not as good as the second Harry Mudd episode but well worth watching just for some fun!
7) What Are Little Girls Made Of?
Kirk discoveres a scientist who is obsessed with making androids
Pretty intelligent episode this one, and quite scary as well. The big bloke, Ruk is very effective. The end is very well done and is quite sad in it's own way. This ep was written by horror writer Robert Bloch and he does a good job. Roddenberry has a habit of mixing with respected writers and have them come on the show, as we shall see.
On a planet that is an exact parallel of Earth, Kirk and Spock discover that all the adults have died and the only people left alive are children.
You have got to be joking!!! A cute kid ep is never a good one, and this one is no exception. Avoid.
9) Dagger Of The Mind
On Tantalus 5, Kirk discovers a virtual torture chamber mental home.
This episode is bad. Very. How is Van Gelder able to get on the bridge so easily? Why has no one sent a security team to this planet? I could go on, but I will say that this ep is only worth watching for the first glimps of Spock's mind meld. Crap, frankly.
10) The Corbomite Manouver
The Enterprise is trapped by a huge ship called the Fesarius, captained by Balok.
Hmmmm... This one is worth watching but it's not hugely entertaining. Once or twice is enough, and when we get to see who Balok really is it's a HUGE letdown.
11) The Menagerie Pt 1
Has Spock committed mutiny? Why has he kidnapped his former captain and taken him back to Talos 4?
Very good one. It raises interesting questions about Spock's loyalty and his state of mind. The way in which The Cage episode is fitted into the story is very well done too. Shatner and Nimoy have settled into their roles well at this point, so Kirk and Spock come across as very real people, which adds to this ep's impact. Great stuff.
12) The Menagerie Pt 2
With Spock undergoing court martial for his actions, Kirk must learn what Spock is up to
The only 2 parter in the original series is also one of the few where the follow-up is as good as the first part. The Talosions' plans are well pieced out and Spock's reasons become clear. The court martial itself is a bit of a let down but this is still a great episode to enjoy. The acting is perfect and the setup and resolution are very good.
13) The Conscience Of The King
An interstellar Shakespeare group may be being fronted by a man responsible for mass genocide.
One of the most forgettable eps of all time. Avoid.
14) Balance Of Terror
Are the Romulans responsible for the destruction of several starbases along the Neutral Zone?
This is the first 'Enterprise in battle' episode and it's great. Apparently the writer watched submarine films to get a handle on this ep's plot. The crewman's suspicion of Spock is understandable, but Kirk's reaction to this is also, and the tension is unbearable at times. Some pretty good special effects too. On the whole I really like this one. Mark Lenard, he gets around a bit dunnee :-).
15) Shore Leave
On shore leave, the crew of the Enterprise encounter weird goings on and thoughts becoming reality.
This ep deserves one word: weird. Although this ep is written by Theodore Sturgeon, it's not his best work. That said if you can stick with it then this ep is fairly enjoyable but it's so strange that it's difficult to sit through. Once again Kirk gets his shirt ripped in a punch up. Maybe Starfleet should hire someone who designs tough all purpose uniforms?
16) The Galileo 7
Spock must take command of a shuttle mission after the shuttle crash-lands on a mysterious planet.
Parts of this ep are great, but the guy who likes riling up Spock-I wish he got eaten by those ape men things! This is an important ep to watch because it shows Spock under pressure and how he copes with different situations. Good stuff.
17) The Squire Of Gothos
Kirk encounters a childish all powerful being
This is one of the best eps of the first season. The plot is intelligent and has been well though out. Trelane is clearly the test-bed for Q in Next Gen. Trelane and Kirk have a lot of fun squaring up to each other and this is a well written ep that is fun and also scary. Good acting here too.
After a starbase is destroyed, Kirk and a lizard like alien must duke it out for survival.
Ah-the Gorn. Why didn't we see more of them? This is a brilliant episode, with lots of action and a well written, thoughtful ending. The scene where Kirk lobs the rock at the Gorn and it doesn't even slow the Gorn down....the look on Kirk's face is priceless! The scene where Kirk makes the cannon is full of tension but you couldn't possibly make gunpowder under those conditions.
19) Tommorrow Is Yesterday
An escape from a black hole leaves the Enterprise stranded in 1969.
This is the first time travel ep, and although a good one, is not the best. The guest star is ok, but a bit flat. A lot of fun scenes especially with the security guards at the airbase! The effects when the ship is going back to the future are very well done for a limited budget!
20) Court Martial
Kirk is charged with negligence after a crewman is 'accidentally' killed.
This is an OK ep, but so many people get killed during the Enterprise's adventures, so why is Kirk pulled up this time? The scene where Spock realises the computer has been tampered with is a good one, especially with Bones winding him up! The court martial scenes seem very 'real' too. Once again, Kirk gets his shirt ripped in a punch up. Pretty good ep, and worth watching more than once.
21) The Return Of The Archons
Kirk must outwit a computer that is controlling a planet.
The first 'Kirk Versus The Computer' ep is nothing special. I haven't seen it for a while so I won't comment on it, yet.
22) The Alternative Factor
Kirk and Spock encounter 2 versions of the same being that are fighting for control of the universe
What a load of bollocks! AAAAAAAAARRGH!
23) A Taste Of Armageddon
Kirk encounters a planet that is at war using computers-against itself!
Same idea as in Return Of The Archons I think, but this is a very good one. The idea of using computers to control wars has all but been done nowadays. Kirk breaks the Prime Directive for the first time. Is the guy ever going to get busted for this? Nope, not by the look of it!
24) Space Seed
The Enterprise discovers a sleeper ship full of genetically enhanced humans from the 20th century, led by Khan.
This to me is the best episode of the first season. The story was years ahead of it's time with its plot of genetics and cryo-sleep. Montalban is great is Khan, a charismatic leader who is a bad guy but has his reasons. Shatner, Nimoy and De Kelley all play off of him and each other. This must be one of the first Spock/Bones argument sessions, and it's worth rewinding a few times! The fight between Kirk and Khan at the end is very well done, and the payoff is interesting. Kirk lets them all off! Of course this leads to the best Star Trek film, The Wrath Of Khan.
25) This Side Of Paradise
Spock has his emotional controls removed by spores and falls for a woman who genuinely loves him
Kirk is a real part pooper in this one! Of course his love for the Enterprise makes it possible for him to break from the spore's influence. Nimoy seems to be enjoying himself in this one. Course if you got to snog Jill Ireland I think you would too! As for the plot, it's not bad, but it's not the most inspiring one either.
26) The Devil In The Dark
After miners on Janus 6 are killed by a strange monster, The Enterprise crew is called in to exterminate the pest.
One of the most intelligent eps ever, this is Shatner's favourite. The plot is excellent and well paced, and the 'villain' actually becomes the 'hero' is great storytelling. The effects look a bit tacky but it doesn't spoil a very enjoyable and thought provoking episode. However, Spock mind-melding with the creature is embarassing!
27) Errand Of Mercy
Kirk and Spock must negotiate with a peaceful race before the Klingons attack the planet.
I like this one a lot, it shows the stupidity of war. The scenes with Kirk and Kor are great and pretty funny, especially when the Organians let slip who Kirk is. The final chat betwen Kirk and Spock is good, letting us know what they both think, too. All in all an interesting episode and fun becuase we see the Klingons for the first time.
28) City On The Edge Of Forever
Kirk must sacrifice his true love to stop a drug crazed Bones changing history
This has been voted the best episode of Star Trek ever. I can see why. It's a real classic, that still holds up today. The scenes between Kirk and Edith Keeler are touching and the ending is heartbreaking. This doesn't stop a lot of humour coming through between Kirk, Spock and Bones though, especially when Spock is trying to build a primitive computer.
29) Operation: Annihilate!
A planet under siege from parasitic aliens must be cleaned up.
Okie Dokie. Star Trek has been great for the past 6-7 eps, this one is ok but a comedown from those. The plot is more than a bit hard to take, it stretches the limits of credibility, even if this is sci-fi. The scene where Jim finds his brother dead is however very well acted even if his brother is William Shatner wearing a slug under his nose!
Kirk must be in need of a shrink by the end of this season! He's been split in half, nearly killed several times, had his true love stolen, his brother killed and Spock nearly permanently blinded!